The definitive answer is NO! Not even close. Corkscrews differ tremendously. Yes, ultimately the goal is getting into that bottle of wine you’ve been desiring after a long day or long week. But what are you going to use to get in there? There are several factors to consider when deciding which type of wine opener to purchase either for yourself or a gift.
7 factors and 1 possible to consider when looking for a corkscrew…
1. Ease of Use
Probably the most important factor to consider is how easy it is to use the corkscrew. While some prefer the more traditional corkscrew, many are gravitating towards openers that require less effort. The top choices when it comes to ease of use, include the lever and electric wine openers. They are simple to use and don’t require much strength or skill and they are fast. They are the best options for people with arthritis, carpal tunnel, or any sort of weakness in the hands. So, if you’re purchasing this as a gift, keep that mind for the recipient.
This is going to depend on what your needs and wants are. If you want something that will last an especially long time, that’s fancy, or a showpiece, you can easily spend a lot of money. However, if you want something simple that just gets the job done without too much effort, there are plenty of options that are inexpensive and a reasonable cost.
To give you an idea, some pocket corkscrews can cost as little as $2. Some more high-end wine openers can cost over $100. There’s even a wine opener that’s over $400- The New York Times wrote about this one! However, many winged corkscrews will cost less than $20. The more advanced lever and electric wine openers are in the $30-$60 price range.
Just like everything else made, corkscrews can vary in quality. If you want something inexpensive and just gets the job done for the present moment, only spend a few bucks. If you want something that’s going to last a little longer or a lot longer than you’ll need to spend a little more. Just another factor to consider when deciding what to purchase.
A lot of the different types of wine openers can bring stylishness to the table. Even some simple screwpulls, or wine keys are available in different colors, finishes or made of rare materials. There are plenty of electric corkscrews available in a variety of colors or provide a beautiful lighting effect when in operation. And then you have legacy corkscrews that are specifically designed with decoration in mind.
If a wine opener that looks as good as it works is a priority for you, then rest assured that you have no shortage of stylish options that will bring some extra beauty to your kitchen counter or home bar.
5. Cork Type
This may not be something that many people consider but should. Believe it or not Depending on how much variety you expect to encounter in the types of bottles you open, as well as the conditions of which you store your wine, you may want to consider having multiple corkscrews nearby designated for different uses. Or you can look specifically for a wine opener that advertises the ability to open both synthetic corks and older natural corks.
While lever corkscrews are easy to use and can even work for the older corks in aged bottles of wine, many of them fall short when it comes to extracting synthetic corks. Wine keys and winged corkscrews, on the other hand, can manage synthetic corks without much problem, however, they aren’t the best for sensitive, brittle and older corks.
6. Worm Length
For the most part, the length of the worm won’t be a problem, but it is definitely something that you should keep in mind. Keep an eye on the reviews, if the worm is too short or too long, you will know it based on the feedback from previous customers.
If the corkscrew has a worm that is too short, it will be hard to get the cork out without it tearing apart on the way out. If if’s too long, then it will push through the cork at the bottom which sucks because cork crumbs can fall back into the wine.
Make sure whatever type of corkscrew you buy has a worm longer than 1.75 inches. That should be long enough to effectively pull out any type of cork in your wine bottle, without sacrificing the integrity of the cork or leaving cork crumbles in the wine.
Are you someone who opens a lot of bottles on-the-go or just on-the-fly? If so, then a wine key or screwpull will be the best choice for you because they are light and small enough to fit in a pocket; a wing corkscrew may work as well just depending on its size.
However, the wine openers to leave at home would probably be most lever corkscrews or electric openers because they’re going to be a little too big. These are best left in a primary location, especially the electric ones since they need to be charged.
8. Showiness- this is the possible!
This is a maybe consider because it really has nothing to do with the functionality or effectiveness of a wine opener. This is for the person who likes to entertain and may care about their wine opener fitting their personal style or home décor.
There are some beautiful and unique wine openers on the market that are sure to be conversation starters. So, if this is important to you, keep it in mind when selecting your new wine opener!